• 2 Posts
  • 22 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: January 13th, 2024

help-circle














  • So what you want to do, effectively, is to have different security requirements for different accounts. Correct? And all in the same file.

    For now I just want to get a few things out of the way:

    • with this strategy, what are you protecting against?
    • how likely is this to happen?
    • what is your contingency plan?

    I believe its good to have different levels of security for different things, but you also have to understand at what cost you need it.

    I can propose a different thing altogether: for the very important passwords, like banks and such, use the pepper method. This means, you have on your password manager part of your password, and a small portion is something you know. Example: generate a 25 chars password, and have at the beginning or end, more 5 chars that you know (can be letters and numbers, and can be something you remember every day, like the first letters of your address plus house number).

    With this approach, there are a couple of benefits:

    • you can still have computacionaly heavy passwords
    • if an attacker gets a hold of your open vault and try to login, it will fail since the password is effectively not complete

    Biggest downside I see is remembering the pepper always. And make sure is not written anywhere. And of course, yo can always argue it is possible at some point to get the correct password with the base password known. But at this point, thus should give you enough time to change it and thwart the attack. Remember: there is no perfect security solution, only sufficiently good ones that can be usable and effective.




  • One of the problems I personally see is the reliance on a standard that was done since the dawn of the internet and got stitches all these years.

    Emails as a service is useful, and has several properties that make sense to exist. However, it is simply not easy nor intuitive to have encryption on it (and even then, there are limitations).

    What we would need on the long run is simply replace email with a common standard that actually encrypts in transit (at very least) with auto negotiated keys on exchange.

    But we would need to change the mind of a lot of people to make that a priority… (For better or worse, it is the market that states the incentives and priorities. And it is abundantly clear security is not on the top list)


  • Never heard of pikvm, it actually looks like a very interesting solution.

    From the previous point, what I mean by headless is basically to go the server, yank the GPU, press power button and it just boots.

    I’ve tried several times, but bios straight up doesn’t let me go on. I’ve seen in a couple of places some mobos simply refuse to boot without a GPU.

    I can see if I can have a decent value for the GPU. If not, I guess it’s doing its job as is. It just feels a waste to have this GPU be used as video for a server.


  • You are for sure right. I did find gaps on my solution right now which is:

    • I have several external disks that only have the information once (some of then quite old).
    • if I aggregate all of those in one spot I for sure need more space
    • right now the ssds are grouped into a lvm to make a logical volume of 3TB (at the time this was OK since I was testing it out for a while). However, one disk fails and I have a problem on my hands.
    • decided to look into ssd prices and my eyes started get watery at how expensive would it be (thus, coming to the realization regarding disk types. Didn’t mention before since my post was getting WAY too long).

    Since I get this now, I am trying to understand better the landscape of solutions that can potentially fit.


  • Thanks for the reply. The breakdown is very good and I can actually see a lot of reasoning on your situation that I also would share (I do not have vast amounts of money to throw at this + only one drive failing and 2 handle the boat sounds about right).

    As for the way to do the software raid, I’ve seen MD somewhere before but I honestly forgot. Since people tend to talk about unraid a lot. From my perspective, I would probably go as simple as possible, although I will be studying how effectively MD works.

    Great reply :) learned a lot