• sugar_in_your_tea@sh.itjust.works
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    5 hours ago

    Hitler was elected

    He absolutely was, and no hate speech law would’ve stopped that because his speech was popular at the time. Don’t forget that.

    Same deal as Trump pretty well

    Not the same at all.

    Nazis don’t deserve fairness.

    They do, under the law.

    Nazis should be met with a fist.

    This is also true. And you have my blessing to punch the next Nazi you see.

    Liberalism is also not a left-wing ideology.

    That really depends on your definition of left vs right.

    The original definition was based on the seating arrangements in the French National Assembly, with those on the left espousing liberalism (revolution, democracy, and secularisation, all liberal concepts) and those on the right preferring the monarchy.

    I personally prefer the two axis “political compass” with economic policy on the left (socialism) vs right (laissez faire capitalism), and government authority on the top (authoritarian) vs bottom (libertarian). US politics is in the top right quadrant, I’d place classical liberalism in the bottom center-right, and I believe I straddle the left/right line in the bottom third.

    Elon Musk loves talking about individual rights

    And he wouldn’t know what those are even if they hit him in the face. All he seems to care about is the same thing as Trump does: seeing his name everywhere. He sort of hitched his wagon to the left when it was convenient getting Tesla visibility, and now he’s hitching to the right now that he’d like to keep out Chinese competition and get his Tesla compensation package approved.

    He doesn’t care about individual rights, he only cares about himself. At least that’s the Musk I see.

    we really need to let Nazis speak you guys

    We need to let everyone speak, but we don’t need to give them a platform. I like this quote:

    "When ignorant folks want to advertise their ignorance, you don’t really have to do anything, you just let them talk.” – Barack Obama

    Let them out themselves, and move on with your day.

    Yeah you’re a liberal. You’re not a leftist or a progressive.

    Exactly. Thanks for recognizing the difference.

    I’m an anarchist… and the government should’ve had them all sentenced to life in prison without outside contact.

    I don’t see how this can possibly follow. An anarchist wouldn’t support the institution of prison, at least not one run by a central authority. Anarchists reject the idea of a monopoly on force.

    there’s probably a good 10 million totally indoctrinated american fascists

    I doubt it, but even if true, that’s <3% of the total population. It looks like >7% of the population identify as LGBT, so why fear a group that’s half the size?

    • LadyAutumn@lemmy.blahaj.zone
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      0
      ·
      4 hours ago

      Well because 10 million people is more than enough to commit crimes against humanity on a frankly ungodly scale. You can commit genocide with those numbers.

      I’m an anarchist, so ideally I’d advocate no government whatsoever in which case we could… shall we say do away with the nazis the way God intended. But we don’t, do we. We live in a society with prisons that currently house millions of people who shouldn’t be there. Nazis should be there, or dead. Either is fine but the least we could do is lock them up and prevent them from interacting with other humans.

      Barrack Obama did nothing to prevent fascism. He was an American imperialist who was directly involved in the mass murder of innocent people in the middle east. I also just honestly love that you defended my strawman version of your arguments, genuinely incredible.

      Saying that you’re not a progressive is as good as saying you don’t really care if Nazis take over again. You’re not invested in it enough to actually try and change anything.

      You also ignored 90% of what I had to say about Hitler. I guess because you have no legitimate response to that? Do you believe that Hitler just came along to find a Germany that was already genocidally bigoted towards queer people and jews? If so you were given a seriously poor education. Germany was arguably the most liberal country in the world leading up to his rise to power. Your failure to understand that Trump played into the exact same political strategies that Hitler did belies your poor understanding of how Hitler came to be democratically elected. The world was not that dramatically different from today. People relied on mass media in much the same ways they do today, just at the time that was print and air waves. Radio stories and misinformation can be broadcast on the same day they happen though, much like social media stories can today. The media is and has always been inherently intertwined with fascism. It’s how you can indoctrinate someone into genocidal bigotry. Tell them everyone is lying to them and secretly jews control everything, and make it so that’s all they hear all the time from birth, and you have created a mass indoctrination machine and predisposed all those people towards genocidal violence.